Feb 15, 2013

The Independent Contractor Status Draws Scrutiny in Dental Practices

This great article was written and shared by Dental CPAs. Check them out at their website:
The government does not hold any grudges against independent contractors. Employers who attempt to avoid paying employment taxes by falsely classifying employees as independent contractors are another story. The government doesn’t like anyone who evades paying taxes.

Independent contractors are valid in various industries given the proper circumstances, including dentistry. However, the government has and will continue to look for abuses of the classification where employers attempt to evade employment taxes.

People who wish to be considered independent contractors (IC) should arrange their circumstances so that their case as an IC is defensible. Some of these circumstances may include: being able to perform work duties freely in the facilities of the owner, getting paid by the project or service (not hourly), paying for their own materials or supplies, using their own equipment, hiring and paying their own staff and control the result of their product or service. If these circumstances are not in place with the owner of the business, the general IC may not be an IC at all, they may be an employee.

One of our client’s is a dental specialist. They don’t own their own practice, they work in offices of other practitioners. They bring their own staff, they control their work process and the outcomes, their services are billed separately, they decide the days they work and because they’re a specialist, the owner can’t supervise their work (tell them how to do it). They also operate from their own entity so the contract is between two entities, an individual is not involved, other than the person providing the service.

Businesses must weigh the degree of the behavioral and financial relationships with workers when classifying them.

The consequences for the owner who misclassifies an employee as an independent contractor could be: A. they’re assessed the employer’s portion of the social security and Medicare tax, B. federal unemployment tax, and, if the owner cannot prove the independent contractor reported the income on their return, they may also assess the employee’s portion of social security and Medicare tax, plus penalties and interest. If the owner had any employee benefit plans that should have covered the IC (health and retirement plans), there could be negative consequences there as well.

If you are an independent contractor, you are self-employed. To find out what your tax obligations are, visit the Self-Employed Tax Center on the IRS website.

You are not an independent contractor if you perform services that can be controlled by the owner (what will be done and how it will be done), you use the owner’s equipment and supplies, you service the owner’s patients or clients and they tell you when to work. This applies even if you are given freedom of action. What matters is that the owner has the right to control the details of how the services are performed. For example, a general dentist is working for another general dentist as an associate, the associate uses the dental staff, they are being supervised by the owner, they are told the hours they are working, they use the owner’s equipment and supplies, and this is the only office they work for. This associate would likely be classified as an employee.

If an employer-employee relationship exists (regardless of what the relationship is called), you are not an independent contractor.

This is a serious issue for owners who are either intentionally or unintentionally misrepresenting relationships with workers. In cases of abuses, the owner is the party that will likely take the beating.
I recall back in the late 80’s when I had a stock broker tax client where all the brokers of this small firm were being treated as independent contractors. The IRS audited the brokerage for several years for the very issue being discussed. The brokers had to submit returns to prove that they were reporting their income correctly and paying the Self-Employment tax while the brokerage firm got slammed for hundreds of thousands of back payroll taxes, penalties, and interest. Ultimately, the brokerage went belly up, many people became unemployed and many clients had to find new brokers or move their money to the brokerage where their broker landed.

We’ve had similar stories on a much smaller scale where IRS reclassified independent contractors as employees and made the client pay back payroll taxes, interest, and penalties. I have only heard of one case where the independent contractor themselves got audited and reclassified as an employee and they got hammered income tax wise because schedule C expenses became miscellaneous itemized deductions subject to limits and their self-employed retirement plan deduction got thrown out.

The bottom line is in just about every audit of a business, one issue the agent must take a look at is the employee vs. independent contractor issue to ensure employers aren’t trying to evade employment taxes.

Thanks again for allowing us to share your article, Dental CPAs!


Social Media Tips for Dental Offices Industry Trends

Social Media Tips for Dental Offices

Mar 20, 2024

Social media is a powerful tool for businesses, including dental offices! Connecting with patients online is crucial to growing your practice. Here are 7 tips for using socia...

How to Handle Negative Patient Reviews Practice Management

How to Handle Negative Patient Reviews

Oct 7, 2021

Bad reviews are a part of the landscape in a digitally connected world, but they can hurt your practice and your ability to attract employees. What do you do if you get a bad ...

Motivating Top Performers In Your Dental Practice Practice Management

Motivating Top Performers In Your Dental Practice

Jun 18, 2021

Top-performing employees are a critical force at your company, capable of 400 percent greater productivity than the average worker, according to research published in Personne...

Dentists: Tips for Successful Mentoring Practice Management

Dentists: Tips for Successful Mentoring

Jun 9, 2021

Being a mentor has many rewards, but like every other skill you have achieved in your career, it requires attention, the ability to adapt to a situation, and a willingness to ...

How to Build a Hybrid Workforce Practice Management

How to Build a Hybrid Workforce

Dec 28, 2020

You have likely seen and heard a lot about the hybrid workforce that is destined to be part of the new World of Work for the foreseeable future. As we get closer to a vaccine ...

Breach of Contract: What Happens Next? Practice Management

Breach of Contract: What Happens Next?

Jul 1, 2020

Most practices have some type of contract with associates. For the most part, these agreements work well. But sooner or later, you are likely to have an employee seek to leave...

Rebooting Your Dental Practice After the Virus Practice Management

Rebooting Your Dental Practice After the Virus

Jun 11, 2020

The coronavirus pandemic has had an enormous impact on the dental industry. We saw one of the biggest unemployment rates of any industry with over 500,000 dental jobs lost, bu...

Perks That Don’t Always Work Practice Management

Perks That Don’t Always Work

Mar 4, 2020

As a practice owner, you're probably already aware that you can save yourself a lot of headaches if you can retain good employees instead of retraining new ones. While employe...

Building an Employer Brand for Your Dental Practice Practice Management

Building an Employer Brand for Your Dental Practice

Feb 19, 2020

Unless your practice exists in a place where there is virtually no competition, you probably already understand the importance of branding in terms of attracting new patients....

Alternative Holiday Celebrations That Will Delight Your Team Practice Management

Alternative Holiday Celebrations That Will Delight Your Team

Nov 27, 2019

How times have changed. For some professional organizations, the big holiday party no longer has the same appeal as it did in years past. An open bar can present more legal an...